• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

FSX Max2012 Animation

Messages
56
Country
netherlands
Goodday gentlemen,

First & Foremost, from reading up about anims here i understand it is the Linear controller that should be used for all animations. Correct ? ( a colleague told me that he thinks it should be TCB... ) I am trying them both and both seem to work. F.i. in FSX i have a correct working Yoke assigned to TCB as well as prop pitch levers assigned to Linear...

Also, i have a problem understanding exactly how 'Make Default' works, the button you get when assigning a controller from the list, accompanied by the text " .... will set Linear (c.q. TCB) Rotation as the default for all Rotation params. " However anims already assigned to TCB remain so when i click 'Make Default' as Linear... Also every new object i select for a new anim seems to have 'Euler XYZ' as default controller not 'Linear' ...

When i go to Preferences/Animation/Set Controller Defaults, Linear doesn't show up in the listing..... ?

Would love to know the deal about 'Make Default' and exactly which of the two controllers, Linear or TCB, i should use.

Secondly : could someone remind me of the correct procedure to get a throttle lever to behave correctly in FSX ? F.i. was it like keyframe '0' = throttle closed, keyframe '100' = full throttle ?... It's not like keyframe '0' = throttle closed, keyframe '50' = full throttle, keyframe '100'= throttle fully closed again, is it ?.... ( you never forget how to ride a bike but this stuff gets snowed under quite easily if you give it up for while :confused: )

Thank you very much for any hints/tips, gents !

Cheers,
Jan
 
Last edited:
Hello Jan,

To NOT answer Your question directly - and to clarify vision in the snow storm - I would have to look that all up in the FSX SDK - It is My Bible ( Sunday Morning Pun ) in all things Modeling - and should point You right down the Path to Clarity - I think I'm up too early !! :);):cool:

Johnman
 
Secondly : could someone remind me of the correct procedure to get a throttle lever to behave correctly in FSX ? F.i. was it like keyframe '0' = throttle closed, keyframe '100' = full throttle ?... It's not like keyframe '0' = throttle closed, keyframe '50' = full throttle, keyframe '100'= throttle fully closed again, is it ?....

It's always trial & error for me, too, but AFAIR: 0 = Full, 50 = Idle, 100 = Reverse.

I don't know if this also applies to piston props, but it surely does to turbine powered aircraft.
 
Jan, Linear animation controllers for movement and rotation should always be used in FSX/P3D. If you've already animated some objects and they have other controllers assigned then you'll have to change the assignments for each object.

To set up default controllers, these screenshots might help: they're from Gmax but Max is almost identical in this respect:–


dg1a.jpg
und5.jpg
 
Just to complete Tom's marvelously clear illustrations, while there I advise setting the Scale controller to Linear as well. One never knows when or if it might be used, but better safe than sorry! ;)
 
Thanks, guys !

@ Johnman: i'm using the P3D SDK but actually i spend an hour or so trying to get the FSX SDK installed as well. I wanted to have a look at the default DC-3 source but no luck. ( do you happen to know if it is actually available for a Max version or is it Gmax only ?...) I got as far as the early FSX SDK version that's on my FSX Deluxe disks but got a weird message when i tried to install SDK SP1A from my Acceleration dvd : you must have FSX SDK SP1A installed before you can install FSX/Acceleration SDK".... SP1A IS what i'm trying to install from that Acceleration disk !?? :confused: That's a catch 22 so i gave up.

@ Bjoern: Ok! Yes, i seem to remember something like that. With the 0 to 100 keyframes the (prop) throttles stop exactly halfway... Thanks for the 0 = Full, 50 = Idle tip !

@ Tom: Yep, that's the exact image (from another thread) i used to get the controller setup. Thanks ! ( been lurking about here a LOT lately. Wouldn't be nowhere without you gentlemen. Thanks a million again for all the great tips and tuts ! You certainly are Da Men ! )

But is this 'Make Default' button really supposed to do something ? I have yet to see anything that verifies that.... I would've thought if i make Linear default this would be what turns up in the Assign Controller dialog everytime i select a new object to be animated. It's always 'Position XYZ' and 'Euler XYZ' for position and rotation that seems to be default.

Or am i taking this the wrong way and leave this Assign Controller alone, don't open it anymore ? Make Linear default one time only and that's that ?.... ( now i think about it that seems logic, i just don't know if i can trust that 'Make Default' thing yet....:rolleyes: )

@ Bill: yes, i'll set the Scale controller to Linear as well. Thanks !

Btw, while writing this i tried 0=Full, 50=Idle for the throttles. Bingo! Thanks again, Bjoern ! :D

As always, thanks a lot, gents, finally getting somewhere ( i think...) :santahat:

Cheers,
Jan
 
Lol, the DC-3 is originally a 3ds Max model supplied with the FSX SDK and lots of people wished it could have been done in Gmax instead, until it was finally converted by torgo3000 and others iirc. It then was 'offically' re-adopted by MS and made available in their downloads...

It's in the FSX SDK, but that's all you need the FSX SDK for because only the P3D SDK will work with Max2012.
 
Thanks, Tom ! Yes, i installed the SDK from my FSX Deluxe DVD but found no DC-3 source file and SP1a wouldn't install from my Accl disk. But i just read in a post by you in another thread that the DC-3 internal model is only present in minimal stage. No gauges nore animations whatsoever ?..... I just wanted to have a look at the most common animations, particularly keyframes. I have lots of Gmax source i created myself, thinking about it it might be a better idea to install Gmax again, i just saw it pass by when i was looking for the SDK on my FSX dvd... :idea:

I suppose when it comes to keyframes nothing has changed between Gmax and Max(2012), right ?
 
Thanks, Tom ! Yes, i installed the SDK from my FSX Deluxe DVD but found no DC-3 source file and SP1a wouldn't install from my Accl disk. But i just read in a post by you in another thread that the DC-3 internal model is only present in minimal stage. No gauges nore animations whatsoever ?

Umm...the default DC-3 uses 2D gauges and thus only posesses gauge polygons. No 3D needles anywhere.

I suppose when it comes to keyframes nothing has changed between Gmax and Max(2012), right ?

Can't speak for Max 2012, but there is absolutely no difference between Max 9 and GMax.
 
I installed the SDK from my FSX Deluxe DVD but found no DC-3 source file...

The source file is in "...SDK\Environment Kit\Modeling SDK\3DSM7\samples\Douglas_DC3"

For animations there is no difference for Max 2012.
 
Thanks, guys. Ah, yes, of course no 3D gauges in the default DC-3. Not that important. I finally managed to install a full FSX SDK and ol' Gmax plus the FSX edition so i can check out lots of stuff now. Got the DC-3 source too but i now have better examples as well.

Many thanks again, gentlemen, as always you've been a great help and more ! Thank you !! :santahat:

Cheers,
Jan
 
Back
Top