• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

FSXA Model/material issues [SOLVED]

Messages
468
Country
ca-ontario
Hi folks, I've run into a couple of issues with one of my current models that has defied all my attempts to fix the problems so I've come for help to see if anyone has seen anything similar or can suggest possible fixes. I'll describe each problem and fixes I've tried below:

Issue #1
Problem

When I built the model I did not activate the specular and bump slots in the material editor at the request of my then painter as she wanted to get the diffuse textures done first and then activate the specs and bumps when she had those textures ready. Things have changed on the team and I now have a new texture artist and we are at the point where we want to activate the specs and bumps in the material(s). I duly checked the required boxes, assigned the correct maps and re-applied the materials to their relevant parts. When I compile the model and test in FSX the spec and bumps are not showing at all. Checking the model in MCX and looking at the texture editor I can see that the diffuse textures are called out but not the specs and bumps. It's as if the changes I made to the material are not being exported to the model.

Fixes Attempted
1. Re-applying the material(s) to the parts.
2. Merging all the parts into a new scene.
3. Copying the material, making minor changes and re-applying to the parts.
4. Re-setting the material(s) to their defaults and then re-making the materials to the same values they were and then re-applying them to the parts.

None of the above have worked. The model still has no specs and bumps in the sim or showing in MCX no matter what I do.

Issue #2
Problem

While checking some other things out I noticed the animation for the crew door was behaving strangely in the sim. It is mounted on two hinges and the top hinge works perfectly but on the bottom hinge the two hinge halves separate as the door rotates. It's almost as if the sim is rotating the door axis in the modelling 'View' mode instead of the modelling 'Local' mode. All the other animations appear to work fine.

Fixes Attempted

1. Re-set scale, transforms and x-form for the part.
2. Re-set the part's transform gizmo to make sure it is perfectly aligned with the orientation required to rotate correctly.
3. Used a spline animation and then set up a parent child relationship with the door as the child of the line.
4. Used a 'dummy' animated as required and then set up a parent child relationship with the door as the child of the dummy.
5. Re-made the part completely (at least the outer skin of the door, the inner parts are children of the outer skin) and animated just the outer skin part.
6. Merged all the parts into a new scene (the same one as above).

None of the above have worked and the part still rotates oddly in the sim despite looking perfect in Max9.

Does anyone have any suggestions for either of the above issues as I am totally baffled by all this now. I've seen bad parts causing issues before and making a new one usually fixes it but nothing I do seems to work for either of the problems.

:banghead: :confused:
 
For problem number two, make sure you are using the Linear animation controller.
 
Hi Tom, I am using the Linear animation controller and it was animated in local view and it still doesn't behave correctly.
 
1) Double check that the materials are exported in FSX format, check the paths to the texture files, check that the textures are actually present for the FSX model and displayed correctly in Imagetool.

2) Re-create the keyframes for the part.
 
1) Double check that the materials are exported in FSX format, check the paths to the texture files, check that the textures are actually present for the FSX model and displayed correctly in Imagetool.
I've done all the above (multiple times) and re-made the materials from scratch and it's still the same, no spec or bump maps exported with the model.

2) Re-create the keyframes for the part.
I've done this multiple times too and even made a new outer door skin to no avail.

Last night I sent my .max file to my texture artist to see if he could export it (admittedly from a much newer version of Max) and while he could see the usual anomalies from not having spec or bump maps in the texture folder in the aircraft viewer in the sim when he tried to launch the flight he didn't have a model (i.e. he was sitting above the runway with no aircraft around him). So it looks like even though he had some model issues the spec and bump maps were active in the aircraft viewer screen.

This led me to suspecting something was corrupt on my end with either my SDK utilities/tools or with Max 9 itself. I tried re-making the paths to the SDK in Max 9 but still had the same issues on testing a new export so now I am wondering if I am going to have to re-install both the SDK and Max 9 again. It's as if changes are not being applied/saved at export time for some reason.

I will need to back up all my custom settings and tools in Max and back up my very modified modeldef file before attempting a re-install though and I am not looking forward to doing that as it could make matters worse than they are!
 
What about the paths to XToMDL.exe or the Modeldef?

It's impossible that things go tits up without reason whatsoever. There has to be a definite culprit for this.
 
I have checked the paths and deleted/re-made them and the problems persist and I agree there has to be a reason but I can't find it/them at the moment.

My latest attempt to fix the problem involved DL'ing the P3D V1.4 SDK to try to eliminate the Accel SDK from the equation. After setting up the correct paths when I try to export the model I now get an out of memory error which I have never seen before from MAX 9. The efforts continue.
 
If you’re going to reinstall the sdk, get the P3D 1.4 sdk; one-shot installation for Max.
 
I did get the P3D 1.4 SDK Tom.

We have some progress, I sent my .max file to Paul Domingue to test and he exported it via 3DS Max 2015 and then sent me the resulting .mdl file back. When I checked the .mdl file in MCX I found that the bump and spec maps were active in the model AND the door animation is perfect with no separation of the bottom hinge! :yikes:

It looks like something is corrupt with my Max install and changes to the materials and animations are not being exported.

Time for a re-install! :eek:
 
OK I am officially a dumb@ss!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :censored::banghead::censored:

I have solved the problem and it came down to pure operator stupidity on my part! My apologies for sending everyone on a wild goose chase!

I used to have the MAX export path set up to my development folder on my development drive and I would then drag and drop the .x file onto a batch file to compile it into a .mdl file.

At some point my path changed and all my recent exports have being going to the default export folder used by Max in the 'My Documents' folder!

All this time I have been compiling the wrong .x file and therefore not seeing the changes I had been making!

I just exported and compiled the correct .x file using the Accel SDK and when checking in the sim I have active spec and bump textures and a correctly animated door!

Excuse me while I crawl into this hole in the ground! :oops:
 
My practice has always been to export from Max directly to my current aircraft's ..\model folder. This way I never loose track of the .x and .xanim files, and also can do an instant reload of the aircraft in the sim and see the results.

But, I too have done silly things and managed to get thoroughly confused!

I'm happy to read that you found your problem Larry and can now continue your work.
 
Back
Top