• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

New to development

Messages
16
Country
us-florida
I have been using 3DS MAX for a little while now. I am familiar with the latest versions (2010-14) and now I want to prepare myself for commercial work, but I find I still have more questions than I have answers. Is there a sticky *README* somewhere that I missed?

I would like to produce aircraft that are commercial products in the real world. Does it require a license from the original manufacturer to model their aircraft in FSX? I know of course that for my own use I can do as I wish, but I mean for distribution later? Has anyone any experience at contacting aircraft manufacturers in real life for projects like this?
 
Welcome to our world, Apache! Great to have a new soul onboard.

Your questions are a little vague. I'll try to answer them.

* There is an SDK Package at Prepar3D.com that you can download freely. This will export models fine. There will be one for 2014 soon. You have 2012 available right now. The SDK kit explains how a lot of things work. FSX/P3D have their own Materials which work in the sim. It explains how to setup your Max installation (Meters, etc), how to setup Materials, how to animate parts for in the sim.


* If doing a payware model, you need to check with that manufacturer for 'permissions'. Usually they are fine with it. Some use a group that pirate a substantial charge from you along with 20% royalty fees with a minimum charge (if you can believe that), so you have to pay them a huge sum, no matter what. THey say they can break it into payments (3) or you can wait and build 3 aircraft and the price goes down. (Swindlers). They use us on firms such as Cessna and Boeing.

Douglas do not like flight sim developers and will seek to shut you down. (Cease and desist order, however you spell that).

Other Corporations value us and will sponsor you with information, photos, etc. It is like free advertising to them to get a very nice version of their planes and helicopters out there to the people. They can become aquainted with their products in their own homes, flight schools can use them, etc, and soon the people that used their sim products are actual pilots on the real aircraft, so it benefits them greatly.

So you need to check with the firm first before doing all the work.

Mind you, if the plane/helo is no longer in production, you can use the shape, as in America, copyrights on shapes of aircraft are no longer copyrightable or valid after they go out of production (several cases of Piper versus the public, and many more other manufacturers found this out in large court trials). But, you cannot use their names or logos (if said businesses are still in business), so you couldn't say Boeing, you couldn't say Cessna. This is what Carenado do with their models.


I hope that covers your questions.


Its a lot to learn. Gauges for the interior, making custom animations of switches, tuning the airfiles so the vehicle handles exact, setting up the sound files, etc, etc, etc. So much to learn and do.

Also, the Payware market can really turn on you fast. Make sure you get things right or people freak out on you over payware. Word travels fast in forums. They will gripe over a compass being 3 degrees off and tell everyone and their friend about it. But freeware makes them all your best friend. But with super detailed models, you cant make this free unless you are setup nice. The time involved is crazy.....



Bill
 
Thank you for the replies!

I'm fresh out of computer animation school, so sounds and animations are nothing new. Probably there are tricks to the way FSX uses them that I will have to get to know (I think that's what you meant). I really want to get my hands dirty working on planes I want to fly before I try to make money with it, but I didn't go to school to give things away forever. Ha!

I appreciate the insight that you gave, for sure. So, it sounds like (for now) I should just browse the Prepar3d SDK, learn what I can, and wait for the 2014 SDK. I have a fondness for canvas and dope planes, and creaky wooden aircraft. Maybe that will change, but it might also make things easier with copyrights for the moment.

I'm sure more questions will come up, but thank you for what you have provided already!
 
Roger that.

Sounds in FSX and P3D are used in each planes soundpack or sound folder. There are also ways of linking the sounds to another planes soundpack. I do that now and then. But the sounds aren't linked to the model directly. Engine sounds are linked to throttle positions (RPM). Basically que's like when you hit the door switch, the door makes a door sound (via that que that occurs). Switches in the virtual cockpit will make a sound per their coding in the switch, which fires off a tag that makes a switch sound you selected for that code and part.

Animations are usually 0-100 and 0-50 for parts and doors. Landing gear is 0-200 with 101 through 200 being suspention and 0-100 being for retraction/extention for RG models.

We have a few 'classics' guys in here that love the fabric and squeaks also. Your 'bretheren' lol...

One guy that used to come in here really did an amazing job on a Stearman. Doug was his name. My goodness, he modeled the entire structure inside the airframe, every nut and bolt on the engine. Incredible work. You could hide the coverings with switches. Something to see.


@Heretic.... yep.. I get those. Takes the wind out of your sails. :banghead:
I got an email 2 days ago, wanted me to change this and that and this and that and this, wanted to know if there was an update coming out. One of my best works yet, and he could only see bad in them. :(
 
@Heretic.... yep.. I get those. Takes the wind out of your sails. :banghead:
I got an email 2 days ago, wanted me to change this and that and this and that and this, wanted to know if there was an update coming out. One of my best works yet, and he could only see bad in them. :(

If this had been done in public, I'd have loved to chew him out for this.
 
Animations are usually 0-100 and 0-50 for parts and doors. Landing gear is 0-200 with 101 through 200 being suspention and 0-100 being for retraction/extention for RG models.

Okay, shows how new I am, I'm guessing. What do the numeric ranges indicate?
 
They represent the range of frames that an animation is defined by. Frames 0-100 are what most animations use, and others use 101-200. You'll have to edit the time configuration within Max to add the extra 100 frames. (You probably already knew that, coming straight from animating school.) :) Also, for any FS animation, make sure your motion controllers are all set to LINEAR by default, not EULER. This is the mistake that I made, and it cost me an entire fully-animated model.
 
Well, knowing how to do it is quite different from knowing why. Intuitively I would think that a landing gear animation would be time constrained, rather than frame limited. So, when I initially saw the number ranges it didn't make sense. Hopefully, little facts like that are revealed in the SDK somewhere?
 
Intuitively I would think that a landing gear animation would be time constrained, rather than frame limited ... Hopefully, little facts like that are revealed in the SDK somewhere?

Ah, this is where FSX/P3D differs from animation sequences. The simulator governs how long an animated sequence takes to play, not the time constraints in 3ds Max. The 100 keyframes for undercarriage to open (for example) take as long as the config file for the model decides and the subsequent 100 keyframes which model the behaviour of the suspension compressing might pass in a blink if the aircraft is landing heavily.

Not everything is fully described in the SDK: like most SDKs, it's written for people who already know what they're doing! Which is why sites like this exist... :)
 
Thank you for that! (And thank you Ozzman, for your insight)

It sounds like FSX/P3D treat all of the available frames and uses them all as keyframes, while interpolating any frames that might be needed for smoothing? What I envision when I consider the situation is a 100 frame animation of a gear retraction/extension sequence that would not look very smooth if the time period ran over ten seconds, for instance. You have me curious enough to fire up FSX and have a good look even though the planes I have in mind will not really use landing gear sequences like that. Open and close canopy animations would fit the bill, of course.

I was taught to actually sit down and sketch out (literally draw) everything before beginning the model process. That way every detail is considered and outlined before work begins, and fewer surprises come up. It really slims down the production time, also.
 
Thank you for that! (And thank you Ozzman, for your insight)

It sounds like FSX/P3D treat all of the available frames and uses them all as keyframes, while interpolating any frames that might be needed for smoothing?

Exactly. I've seen retraction/extension sequences much longer than 10s and very smooth!
 
The sim engine (FS or P3D) does indeed interpolate the positions in-between "frames" when playing the animation, which is precisely why the animation's three controllers (Position, Rotation, Scale) must be set to Linear.
 
Back
Top