• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Bell 429...boolean mess.

Messages
1,451
Country
mexico
Hello lads

I have read all post regarding boolean operations in FSDS and also the Adam's 3rd book (half of it). I have a bitter feeling right now because I've spent almost one month to finish the extenal model just to hit my head with a wall (again...). My work will be directly into the trash, because I need "to reshape it again" in order to perform a clean cut in my windows (I did 10 times the fuselage...).

Once I'm done with this issue, I am pretty sure that more problems will come later when I get into the VC design. In this desperate moment, I deleted all unnecesary parts and left only the fuselage to experiment and saved the project as "boolean_experiment" (of course I have 18 back ups with all steps done so far).

I am trying to do the "cabin and cockpit housings" first. From my point of view, I know exactly what I want to do... so the boolean operation's devil did its first visit. :eek:

I'm sure that the time and effort to do what I want will exhaust all my Jedi powers (I'm the very newest Padawan compared with all of you).:(

It seems to me that this project will take 10,000 years to finish and I am a little bit frustrated. I just want to show you the project's progress so far:

Externalmodel70.jpg


I hope you like it.
Sergio.
 
Not quite sure what you're asking here, but according to the title I'm guessing that you are having trouble with a mess of vertices after the Boolean operation. Well, if that's the case, you're always going to have extra vertices left over afterwards. I'm not very familiar with FSDS, but in most 3D apps, there are tools to remove or merge vertices in the mesh. This is just one of those things that requires some manual clean-up. However, there are some preliminary measures you can take, the most significant of which would be to remove smoothing before you make the cut. I'm pretty sure FSDS has "smoothing groups" or the equivalent...but please don't kill me if it doesn't. ;) Another measure you can take is to ensure that both objects are completely "water-tight", meaning that the mesh must be completely closed in with no holes. Usually the cuts are a little more manageable when both objects meet these conditions. But as I said before, there is almost always some manual tweaking to be done afterwards.

Hopefully this helps.
 
Last edited:
That's the main body of the problem. To many "detailed, annoying, well shaped in vane, create but better destroy'em later polys...":rolleyes:
I think that I will use point deletion and reconstruct the fuselage again... (the 11th time). With FS world, all things are messy, complicated and annoying;
this is for people like me with little patience. I'm sure that many off you have done this for years, I only have "1 month old" in the designing stuff,
so you can consider me consider me a "spoiled & whimsical boy".

Thank you very much.
Your friend, Sergio.
 
Last edited:
Ozzman speaks wisdom.

Anytime we do Booleans, we have to clean them up afterwords.

When doing Booleans, make sure the fuselage and the Boolean cutting part are the same degree of sophistication (polygon counts per area). Make sure they are both Editable Polys. Then do a Boolean. If they do not take the first time, move them a very small amount and try again (if things go wrong). You don't want to put lines over lines that are both parallel.


An option is to cut the Edges out of the Polygons manually. Create a Spline template of the windows, delete half of the fuselage (one side) and then manually cut the lines out. This way you can control the amount of Vertices you have 'exactly' and using the Spline template as your guide to cut by. This is what I do now.

Nice looking Helo. Great job so far.


Do you build these with 'saves' along the way? We save in steps. I have had like 500 save steps before in some projects. Each time you save, then save again as next number up. This way you can backstep to an early version if you make a mistake.
 
Lionheart :wizard:

Thank you as well for sharing your expertise with me. I was thinking that perhaps would be better to joining parts than cutting them via boolean ops.
I will follow all recomandations and see what happens. I need some time to experiment with different ideas and make a decision on which work method will suit better for me. Regarding the number of saved files, I have 18 backups till now. It's a great idea to do it more often, thanks again.

On the other hand, I will quote something from you: "Nice looking Helo. Great job so far."
Comming from you... WOW!!! Maybe I've done something right after all.

Kindes regards, your friend
Sergio.
 
Last edited:
I am not at all familiar with FSDS, just for the record! However, I found after some years of experience with GMax that one should ideally only do one "Boolean" operation...

...by this I mean that I would create all of my "cutter objects" that I need, then do the "Boolean" cut.

Since moving up t Max9, and now Max2012, I totally ignore the simple "Boolean" tool and use the "Pro-Boolean" tool instead. :wizard:
 
Lads... Success in the attempt! :D

I got it know; the main idea for this is now crystal clear for me. However I had to "disrupt" my original polygons and that is somehting I don't like. I will gather all pictures in order and I will explain what I did step by step; I guess that will be helpful gathering all ideas and put them in a single post. For now, here it's the result:

Firstbooksucceed.jpg


Summarizing:
Once you got the main idea, this operation is quite simple. The VERY BAD issue with all of this, is that you need to rearrange your original part in order to avoid lines to intersect each other. This is the main drawback with FSDS (from my point of view, of course). On the other hand, Max2012 is a super sophisticated 3D design tool with a bunch of engineers behind it; and as you may know, they create powerfull tools that -for sure- deals with all problems mentioned. With Gmax and FSDS, you MUST cleverly select from the very beggining of your project, what sections will be cut and hence, avoid to create super details in this special places. Just my two cents in this regard.

Thank you all!
Sergio.
:p
 
Last edited:
Good tools are really nice if you can afford them. Until then, you can really sharpen your skills by learning the basics.



Just a side note. When I cut parts out, like doors, I usually will map them when they are still joined, 'then' detach the parts.

[CUTTING A DOOR]
* Cut edges
* Map the UVW's on entire fuselage
* Detach
* Animate

This way, you don't have to try to align graphics to the doors, as it will never be 100% perfect.
 
Lionheart

Thank you for another advice. I think that "accidentally" did what you are saying. I kept all pieces until I have the time to study all after the boolean process. My bad memory can point me to do some monkey business with my model, so, I have a "test room". :D

Thank you.
Your friend, Sergio.
 
I am not at all familiar with FSDS, just for the record! However, I found after some years of experience with GMax that one should ideally only do one "Boolean" operation...

Experience pays I think. We were taught in animation school to avoid Boolean operations. I went into animation thinking Boolean processes were great, but supposedly there are a lot more potential pitfalls you can run into.
 
Hi,

You can always "attach" the door to the fuselage piece, do the texture mapping on the whole thing, and then "detach" it after that.
 
Thanks!

Tom:

Thank you very much for your teaching! I am still testing some with boolean operations. I hope I do not spoil my model:eek:
Sergio.
 
I have done quite a few planes before. If I were you, I would try out hand cutting your windows and doors if you can do that in FSDS. You can in Max and Gmax. Just create a very nice, rounded Spline template that is the exact shapes of the windows and doors (from side view) and use that as your cut pattern and start cutting, placing Vertices into the middle of Polygons along your Spline pattern, then connect the lines, and Voila. Done, and you have the exact amount of Vertices you want and need, not 4,000 like a Boolean can do. :S


Bill
 
BTW, in GMAX when you "Attach" a piece, it becomes a separate Element. So when you are ready to detach it, add an Edit Mesh modifier, go to Element sub-mode, and click the area you want to detach. Choose Detach and give it a name. Quick and easy.

BTW, I'm lazy and don't want to figure out how to keep the pivot point for an animated part (like the rudder) when I attach it for texturing (to the vertical stab). So I:

1. Clone the rudder.
2. To the original rudder I add an extra polygon far away from the original part (create a plane as a new part and attach it).
3. Attach the cloned rudder to the vertical stab and texture the entire part.
4. Go to Element sub mode and select the rudder area.
5. Click Detach button and leave the default name.
6. In the original rudder, delete all polygons except the one you created as a plane.
7. To this skeleton rudder, attach the detached rudder clone. Now it has the new texture mapping with the original pivot point.
8. Delete the extra plane/polygon.

There is probably a faster way but when I need to do it, this procedure is the one I remember. :)
 
BTW, in GMAX when you "Attach" a piece, it becomes a separate Element. So when you are ready to detach it, add an Edit Mesh modifier, go to Element sub-mode, and click the area you want to detach. Choose Detach and give it a name. Quick and easy.

BTW, I'm lazy and don't want to figure out how to keep the pivot point for an animated part (like the rudder) when I attach it for texturing (to the vertical stab). So I:

1. Clone the rudder.
2. To the original rudder I add an extra polygon far away from the original part (create a plane as a new part and attach it).
3. Attach the cloned rudder to the vertical stab and texture the entire part.
4. Go to Element sub mode and select the rudder area.
5. Click Detach button and leave the default name.
6. In the original rudder, delete all polygons except the one you created as a plane.
7. To this skeleton rudder, attach the detached rudder clone. Now it has the new texture mapping with the original pivot point.
8. Delete the extra plane/polygon.

There is probably a faster way but when I need to do it, this procedure is the one I remember. :)



Genius....! Thanks Tom.
 
:D

Lads, thank you very much!

I am learning how to do this techniques in the best way posible. I got ride of the boolean operations and a few minutes ago I was able to create my doors without it. In a matter of fact, my failures are because I can't follow very good every point in the mesh; however, I did what you've told me and following some instructions from Dave Eckert as well. In a few minutes, I will post my VERY SLOW progress (nevertheless it's better than nothing, right?) :p

Kindest regards,
Sergio.

P.S. You're very kind and friendly people, I am very thankful.
 
Last edited:
Hello lads!

Bill:
I am strugling with this already, when I do a template, is made from a 2D plane. In my case, from the right view (YZ plane). Once the template is done, then I extruded in the X axis and a very neat image from it is viewed from the right view. The main trick in FSDS is that, create a face from a template (I only were instructed in one tutorial to use the first cross section from the extrution). The main trouble, is to drag the points in the X axis ONLY to match with the cross sections over the front view (YX plane). Since it's very difficult to follow every point, my first attempt looks like this:

429_0414-12-2014.jpg


As you may see, due the lack of cross sections used it is almost impossible to "paste" the face as if it were a sticker into the fuselage contour.

In my second attempt, I used the fuselage cross sections and I arranged all points in its mesh as follows:

429_0214-12-2014.jpg


Then, I create polygons from points in order to "merge them" as a new part: my door. Just after that, I deleted all points in the fuselage mesh as you suggested:

429_0114-12-2014.jpg


429_0314-12-2014.jpg


As you may see, there are no more gaps between the fuselage and both doors are identical; furthermore, both have the exact fuselage curvature (the original was copied and then flipped in the X axis). On the other hand, again and again I am facing another problem... Once I have deleted all points, I cannot add new cross sections into the fuselage. :banghead:

At this moment, I am doing the pilot door as I did in my first attempt (I will deal with gaps again...). This is because I can't do more precise adjustments in the cross sections to match the door shape. And this issue will continue with the windshield as well.

429_0514-12-2014.jpg


I will try to do my very best to give you more pics as soon as I figured out how to solve this issues. Sadly, FSDS froze and stopped working when I was doing the pilot door... :(
Fortunately, I saved the work very often! And now I will try to resume my last operation. Thank you all for your kind help.

Kindest regards,
Sergio.

P.S. I will try to "join" this knowledge with this:
http://www.daviator.com/tutorial3/

Just in case someone has missed it, you can visit Dave's website with almost all tutorials available. Some of them are viewlets made with java and at least for me, they can't be watched in firefox:
http://www.daviator.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=47&Itemid=53
 
Last edited:
Hello lads!

Unfortunately, for the doors and windows I had to use Boolean operations very often. I was not able to perform the "one on one" polygon creation and point deletion in order to create new parts as you've tried to teach me before (that's very unfortunate for me). The main reason, is because when I went to my original fuselage part, I add a lot of cross sections in order to create by "point by point selection" new parts. That was a mess... when I created a "satisfactory" shape, then I chose the points, then I created new polygons and finally I splitted them into a new part.

After that, when I deleted the "inner" points to make a gap (for example, a door), the whole piece (fuselage and the new part cut) does simply does not match together; this gets even worst, in many cases, I was not able to delete points without seriously affect the fuselage integrity.

As a result, I was forced me to get my hands dirty and finally chose to use Boolean operations. Now I have a real mess to deal with: A lot of cleaning work!!!:confused:

I will try to clean unnecessary points and polygons in ALL those new pieces without affecting its main shape. Just to mention, I was about to drive me crazy with all things I've done and the final fuselage cuts will be even worst... the windshield and the floor glasses (I don't know the exact part name in english...). Well, here we go with some images:

Rear door cut:
Bell_42922-12-2013_07.jpg


Rear door windows:
Bell_42922-12-2013_06.jpg


Pilot door cut:
Bell_42922-12-2013_05.jpg


Pilot door window:
Bell_42922-12-2013_04.jpg


Fuselage cut, join, chopped, abused... you name it!
Bell_42922-12-2013_03.jpg


And a couple of pics once the model have been compiled:
Bell_42922-12-2013_01.jpg


Bell_42922-12-2013_02.jpg

That's my lousy job at this stage :(
Sergio.

P.S. Any ideas on how to clean this mess is very welcome!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top