• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

FS2004 Shading Issue

Messages
292
Country
unitedkingdom
I am probably not the first to experience this problem, I have searched for threads regarding this issue without success, my problem is that the aircraft that I am currently modelling has 2 baggage compartments in it's nose, the compartment doors have rounded corners & I have cut these corners using splines & shapemerge & after tidying up the vertices & everything is smooth I detach the doors from the fuselage, but the doors are a different shade to the fuselage, I have tried detaching them in both editable poly & editable vertex modes, smoothed & unsmoothed. I have the same problem if I detach the same polygons without corners cut.

I appreciate any help with this.
 

Attachments

  • Door Attached.PNG
    Door Attached.PNG
    77 KB · Views: 507
  • Door Detached.PNG
    Door Detached.PNG
    69.5 KB · Views: 546
That's a common problem, rounded corners create many small triangles (check triangulation), and these typically create shading artefacts.

It's generally a good idea to make a rectangular bounding box on the mesh first, and then project the shape/merge shape into this bounding box.

Don't forget, before you detach the door, do your UVW mapping.

Better upload a picture for problems like this, there might be various other reasons.
 
I have uploaded some screenshots, I did divide the polygons where I thought would help with triangulation & not have big or is it long triangles. The thing is, I have the shading problem even if I detach the same polygons before shapemerging the round corners.
 
Yes long triangles are the usual suspects.

But really, there's nothing wrong with your detached part. Slap on a texture, draw in the panel lines, look at it in sim, because that's the proof of the pud, and I dare say it'll be just dandy.
 
Thanks, this is only my 2nd model & I am just a beginner, you say to do the UVW mapping before detaching, but what I was planning to do was to detach the baggage compartment doors, animate them & then clone this left fuselage half to become the right fuselage side along with the baggage compartment doors & animations & then I would do the passenger door on the port side of the fuselage, how would I be able to do that with it UVW mapped.
 
Thanks, this is only my 2nd model & I am just a beginner, you say to do the UVW mapping before detaching, but what I was planning to do was to detach the baggage compartment doors, animate them & then clone this left fuselage half to become the right fuselage side along with the baggage compartment doors & animations & then I would do the passenger door on the port side of the fuselage, how would I be able to do that with it UVW mapped.

It's easy:

Just remember to map before you animate in this case. Mirror the fuselage over, including the baggage door, which you shouldn't have detached yet, and then cut out the passenger door. This way, you can map everything before detaching any doors. The same can go for passenger windows.

A trick I've found that works wonders for UVW mapping is setting the map size to the same dimensions for most of your aircraft's parts. Pick a size (yours looks like a relatively small aircraft, so maybe 10m x 10m? Perhaps larger, just pick dimensions that you can remember easily. ;)) If you were to make a mistake and have to go back, remodel, and remap a part or 12, a constant map size will work wonders when you want to have everything "fit" together. You won't have to scale it to match the rest of your mesh, and it can just be moved into position among your model's UVW map.

ANOTHER cool trick is to select multiple objects that you want to map from the same axis on the same sheet, even if they are detached and animated, and apply a single UVW map modifier to all of them, then an Unwrap UVW to move things around and/or make some final tweaks. Now you've saved yourself the trouble of going from Editable Mesh > UVW Map > Unwrap UVW > Mesh Select > UVW Map > Unwrap UVW...................... and so on. Just 3 simple steps to this one. :D
 
Hi,

I don't see a big difference doing what you say before or after UVW Mapping. Yes, if done before there will need to be some remapping, but not much more than you will need to do afterwards.

In GMAX that multiple selection, then UVW Map, followed by a UVW Unwrap has never worked for me. The vertices jump around unpredictably in the UVW Unwrap window.

But you can always Attach the door(s) to the main fuselage, and after UVW Mapping/Unwrapping you can use the Element sub mode (Edit Mesh) to quickly select the door(s) and then Detach it. Easy peasy. Attaching objects combines them as separate Elements.
 
But you can always Attach the door(s) to the main fuselage, and after UVW Mapping/Unwrapping you can use the Element sub mode (Edit Mesh) to quickly select the door(s) and then Detach it. Easy peasy. Attaching objects combines them as separate Elements.

Thanks Tom, your a legend!! reattaching the doors does not improve the appearance, I thought that when I am ready to UVW map the fuselage I could include as a multiple selection all of the other parts I want included with the fuselage mesh, doors etc. I am still learning & am not familiar with all of the Gmax functions available.
 
Glad to help. As long as the doors are separate pieces, they will have different shading in many cases. Not much you can do about that. But once you get them textured, much of that will be hidden.
 
Hi,

In GMAX that multiple selection, then UVW Map, followed by a UVW Unwrap has never worked for me. The vertices jump around unpredictably in the UVW Unwrap window.

That's strange, for the short time I used Gmax, that was the only way I could map objects without pulling my hair out in frustration. I think it helps to apply the UVW map, convert to Editable Mesh, THEN unwrap it with the selection still intact...But I'm not positive. I haven't used Gmax in quite some time, but I know that it works perfectly fine in 3ds Max.
 
Hi,

Yes, I hear it does work fine in 3DSMax. But the Attach/Detach method is pretty quick and easy.
 
Also... Make sure all parts have their Gizmo's pointed upwards properly. The fuselage might be pointed forwards instead of up, mis-aligned with the scene/world.
 
Together with a constant UVW Map size, you can place a Dummy object which the Map gizmo is aligned with when mapping each object in a set you want to keep grouped together on the texture sheet. This gives a mapping with wing top, aileron top, fuselage top surfaces perfectly aligned with each other for painting. Another dummy could align wing bottom, aileron bottom, fuselage bottom and flap bottom surfaces together on the texture sheet.
You have to work out where to place the dummy for best results, but alignment is easy once that's done.
 
Does not matter if you map before you cut, because your going to have to remap after cutting anyways. But mapping first does help keep the mapping aligned.

To make sure the lighting stays the same there are a couple rules.
Rule1 Do not bevel the outer edge of the door!
Rule2 Make sure you use the same material ID number and smoothing group!
Also
Make sure you use the same mapping area on the texture for the fuselage and door so it matches correctly for paint theme!
 
Back
Top